George Jones walked out of the studio when they finished "He Stopped Loving Her Today." According to Billy Sherrill, the last thing Jones said about the recording was "Nobody'll buy that morbid son of a bitch." He was wrong, of course, but the fact that he said it at all tells you everything about what those sessions cost him, and what the song required him to find inside a life that was, by 1978, badly coming apart.
The song was written by Bobby Braddock and Curly Putman, two of Nashville's most accomplished craftsmen. The premise was stark and simple: a man might love a woman so completely that the only thing capable of ending it was death. Braddock and Putman built a song around that idea, worked it through many drafts, and eventually brought it to producer Billy Sherrill. Sherrill, who had been George Jones's producer since Jones joined Epic Records in 1971, believed the song belonged to one singer. He was certain enough that he kept a notebook, reportedly about an inch thick, filled with rewrites and possible revisions, working the song toward something he could hear in his head and that Jones, for a long time, could not.
Jones was introduced to the song in 1978, and he hated it. He thought it was too long, too sad, and that no radio station would touch it. He also kept drifting toward the melody of Kris Kristofferson's "Help Me Make It Through the Night," which prompted Sherrill to tell him, bluntly, that Kristofferson would probably agree it was his melody. The sessions were difficult in a way that went beyond creative disagreement. Jones was, by his own later admission, deep into a dependence on alcohol and cocaine that had made him unreliable and sometimes unreachable, working through the wreckage of his marriage to Tammy Wynette, which had ended in 1975. The recording stretched across nearly two years. Sherrill recalled that the spoken recitation near the end of the song was laid down eighteen months after the opening verse. That gap is a portrait of a man barely holding together.
What Sherrill was building in those sessions, at CBS Studio B in Nashville, was a frame strong enough to hold whatever Jones could give on any given day. The personnel reads like a roll call of the Nashville A-Team: pianist Hargus "Pig" Robbins, pedal steel guitarist Pete Drake, guitarist Pete Wade, drummer Jerry Carrigan, and harmonica player Charlie McCoy. The Jordanaires sang backing vocals alongside Millie Kirkham, whose high note threads through the recording with a quiet, aching precision. The track was cut to an Ampex tape machine at 15 ips Dolby, and Sherrill's production, which he would later describe as simply a matter of showing up and waiting, was in fact a sustained act of patience and belief. He moved the chorus to the very end of the song, breaking from standard country structure, and gave the closing recitation its own weight and stillness. The song does not build to a climax. It arrives at a fact.
The single was released on April 14, 1980. Jones was still skeptical. The song reached number one on the Billboard country chart on July 5, 1980, becoming his first solo chart-topper in six years. The album it led, *I Am What I Am*, followed in September 1980 and peaked at number 7 on the Billboard country album chart, Jones's first top 10 album in five years. The success of the single led CBS Records to renew his contract and sparked a second chapter in a career that had seemed, to many observers, nearly finished. The song won CMA Song of the Year in both 1980 and 1981, and earned Jones a Grammy Award for Best Male Country Vocal Performance. Jones would later say that "a four-decade career had been salvaged by a three-minute song." He meant it as gratitude, but it also carries the weight of how close the thing came to never existing at all. Bobby Braddock, hearing the finished record, said the artist and the production had elevated the song to a place the writing alone could not have reached.
On May 2, 2013, Alan Jackson sang "He Stopped Loving Her Today" at George Jones's funeral. The choice required no explanation. The song had already done the work of being the truest thing Jones ever committed to tape, and it did that work by asking him to go somewhere he did not want to go, in a condition he was barely surviving, with a producer who refused to let him quit. The song is about a man who could not stop loving someone even when it destroyed him. Jones understood that feeling from the inside, and Sherrill understood that Jones understanding it was the whole point.